Contradicting the State: Forensic Failures and Discrepancies in Case CF-001

This report analyzes the documented contradictions between official state narratives and physical evidence in the case of Danish Thanvi (CF-001). We focus on the 'Critical' discrepancies identified in the HRPM platform, including the alleged forgery of official memos and the forensic impossibility of 'Initial Technical Reports' produced by investigators.

Key Findings

Broken Chain of Custody: Critical failures in the handling of digital evidence seized during regulatory raids at BCG offices.

Evidence Fabrication: Allegations of forged official memos and perjury by state actors to justify ongoing investigations.

The Mobina Sohail Incident: Discrepancies surrounding FIR 673/25, where a 'friendly visit' followed an alleged theft, undermining the credibility of the complainant's narrative.

Evidence & Data

On February 9, 2026, a 'Challan Mobi FIR' was added to the case file. However, our investigation reveals a fundamental impossibility regarding the 'Initial Technical Report' cited by the investigation body. Standard forensic protocols require a specific expertise and time frame that were bypassed in this instance. Furthermore, the roles of Officer Khalid Hussain and ASP Maria Khan are under scrutiny for their supervisory conduct during these procedural irregularities. The most glaring discrepancy remains the 'Mobina Sohail incident' (FIR 673/25), where the timeline of a friendly visit contrasts sharply with subsequent criminal allegations.

Legal Framework

Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) Section 463-471: Dealing with forgery and the use of forged documents as genuine.

Qanun-e-Shahadat Order (1984): Standards for the admissibility and integrity of evidence in Pakistani courts.

ICCPR Article 14: The right to a fair and public hearing by a competent, independent, and impartial tribunal.

Recommendations

Immediate dismissal of all evidence found to have a broken chain of custody.

Prosecution for perjury against officials who submitted forensically impossible 'Initial Technical Reports.'

Read the full case file on HRPM for more details on Case CF-001.