The Narrative Shift: Analyzing Inconsistencies in Testimony and FIR 1626/25

In Case HRPM-MLORJ30M (Parishay Khan vs CDA Islamabad), recent court filings and witness statements reveal significant inconsistencies. By cross-referencing the Challan U/S 173 Cr. P.C submitted for Farzana Bashir Marwart against the initial FIR 1626/25, this report identifies a pattern of narative shifts intended to manipulate the judicial process in the District Courts (East) of Islamabad.

Key Findings

Shifting Accusations: Statements made by Farzana Bashir (daughter of Bashir Ahmed) have evolved significantly since the incident at the CDA Stray Dog Population Control Centre.

Procedural Anomalies: Multiple hearings scheduled for 2026-02-20 indicate a rushed or repetitive procedural cycle that obscures the factual basis of the criminal charges.

Social Media Discrepancies: Public statements by figures like SafinaKhann conflict with the formal evidence presented in the Challan before Ahtsham Muqarrab.

Evidence & Data

Investigation into FIR 1626/25 shows that the initial reports of the incident did not include the specific criminal charges later added to the Challan. This 'narrative creep' is a common tactic in systemic corruption cases where state institutions like the CDA are involved. The data shows that the 2026-02-20 hearing serves as a critical juncture for addressing whether the accusations against Parishay Khan are substantiated by physical evidence or merely by the evolving testimonies of the accused parties.

Legal Framework

Pakistan Penal Code (PPC): Provisions regarding false testimony and malicious prosecution.

ICCPR Article 9: Liberty and security of person; protection against arbitrary arrest.

Constitution of Pakistan, Article 4: The right of individuals to be dealt with in accordance with law.

Recommendations

A comprehensive review of the social media evidence (SafinaKhann) vs. the formal police statements.

Judicial scrutiny of the CDA's internal reports regarding the Stray Dog Population Control Centre incident.

Read the full case file on HRPM for Case HRPM-MLORJ30M.